Gel vs Pencil Eyeliner: A Comprehensive Guide

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Gel vs Pencil Eyeliner

Choosing the right eyeliner can make or break your makeup game. Gel and pencil eyeliners stand out as popular choices in eyeliners. Let’s delve into the distinctions between gel and pencil eyeliner to help you effortlessly achieve the perfect look.

What is Gel Eyeliner?

Gel eyeliner, a beauty enthusiast’s secret weapon, offers a smooth and precise application. This creamy formula is often housed in small pots and applied with a brush, giving you control over the thickness of your lines.

What is Pencil Eyeliner?

Pencil eyeliner, the classic choice, comes in a retractable or sharpenable form. Its convenient design makes it a go-to for quick, on-the-go makeup applications.


Gel Eyeliner

Pencil Eyeliner


Creamy and smooth

Firm and can be waxy or creamy


Requires a brush or applicator for precision

Can be applied directly without additional tools


Often more intense and bold

Generally gives a softer and more natural look


Ideal for creating sharp lines and detailed looks

Can be less precise, especially for intricate designs


May smudge if not set with powder

Tends to smudge less


Generally longer-lasting, resistant to water and sweat

May fade or smudge sooner, especially in humid conditions


Suitable for creating various eyeliner styles

Limited when it comes to creating certain looks

Ease of Use

May have a learning curve for beginners

Easy for beginners and quick application


Typically comes in pots or tubes, may be bulkier

Compact and easily portable


Requires cleaning of brushes/applicators

No additional maintenance needed


Often more expensive due to the formulation

Generally more affordable

Check Price On Amazon

Check Price On Amazon

Pros and Cons:

Gel Eyeliner


  • Long-lasting
  • Intense Color
  • Versatility
  • Precision


Application Technique
Drying Time

Pencil Eyeliner


  • Convenience
  • Beginner-Friendly
  • Quick Application
  • No Drying Time


Less Intense Color
Sharpening Required

Expert Insights on Gel vs Pencil Eyeliner

Drawing from personal experiences, many makeup artists emphasize the versatility of gel eyeliner for intricate designs while praising the quick and effortless application of pencil eyeliner for everyday wear.

Gel vs. Pencil Eyeliner Section

Gel vs pencil eyeliner: a choice that defines your style. While gel eyeliners offer unparalleled precision and intensity, pencil eyeliners cater to those seeking a softer, more natural look. Ultimately, the decision rests on your makeup goals, skill level, and personal preferences.


Are gel eyeliners suitable for beginners?

Absolutely! While there’s a learning curve, practice makes perfect. Start with small strokes and build confidence gradually.

Can I use a pencil eyeliner to create bold looks?

While pencil eyeliners are better suited for softer looks, you can layer the product for added intensity. However, achieving intricate designs might be easier with gel eyeliner.

Do gel eyeliners smudge easily?

No, gel eyeliners are known for their smudge-resistant formula. Once set, they stay in place, offering long-lasting wear.

How often should I sharpen my pencil eyeliner?

Sharpen your pencil eyeliner to maintain a fine tip for precise application. A sharp tip ensures a clean and defined line.

Can I use gel and pencil eyeliners together?

Certainly! Experimenting with both types can create unique effects. Use gel for a bold upper line and pencil for a softer lower line for a balanced look.

Is there a difference in removing gel and pencil eyeliners?

Due to its water-resistant nature, removing gel eyeliner may require a dedicated makeup remover. Pencil eyeliner typically comes off easily with regular makeup remover.


In the gel vs pencil eyeliner debate, there’s no one-size-fits-all answer. It boils down to personal preferences and the desired makeup outcome. “Go ahead and try new things, enjoy the process, and don’t be afraid to express your creativity!”

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top